Can Parliament amend any part of the Constitution, even the parts that make it a Constitution? In 1973, thirteen judges of the Supreme Court sat together to answer this question, and their answer shaped Indian democracy for the next fifty years. The case began with a small religious monastery in Kerala and ended with the basic structure doctrine: the idea that Parliament can amend the Constitution, but cannot destroy its core identity.
Contents
- Background: The Fight Before 1973
- Facts of the Case
- Key Questions Before the Court
- The Judgment: What Was Decided
- What Is Part of the Basic Structure?
- Cases After Kesavananda
- Criticism and Debate
- Exam Tips
- FAQs
Background: The Fight Before 1973
From the first years of the Republic, the Court and Parliament disagreed on one question: does Article 368 let Parliament take away Fundamental Rights? The answer changed over time.
| Case | Year | Holding |
|---|---|---|
| Sankari Prasad v. Union of India | 1951 | Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights. An amendment is not "law" under Article 13. |
| Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan | 1965 | Earlier view followed by majority, though some judges raised doubts. |
| I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab | 1967 | 11-judge Bench (6:5): Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights. An amendment is "law" under Article 13. |
After Golaknath, Parliament responded with a series of amendments:
- 24th Amendment (1971): declared that Parliament can amend any provision of the Constitution, and that Article 13 does not apply to constitutional amendments.
- 25th Amendment (1971): reduced the right to property by limiting "compensation", and added Article 31C, which protected laws made to give effect to certain Directive Principles from challenge under Articles 14, 19 and 31.
- 29th Amendment (1972): placed two Kerala land reform laws in the Ninth Schedule.
Facts of the Case
Swami Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru was the head of the Edneer Mutt, a religious institution in Kasaragod, Kerala. The Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 and its 1969 amendment allowed the State to take over part of the Mutt's land. In March 1970, he filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court under Article 32, claiming violation of his rights to property (Article 19(1)(f) and Article 31) and to manage religious affairs (Articles 25 and 26).
While the case was pending, the 24th, 25th and 29th Amendments were passed, and the petition grew into a challenge against all of them. Because the Court had to consider whether Golaknath was correct, a Bench of 13 judges, the largest in Indian history, was constituted. The famous lawyer Nani Palkhivala argued for the petitioners.
The hearing ran for 68 days, from 31 October 1972 to 23 March 1973, and the judgment was delivered on 24 April 1973.
Key Questions Before the Court
- Is Golaknath correct, or can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights?
- Does the amending power under Article 368 have any limits?
- Are the 24th, 25th and 29th Amendments valid?
- Is Article 31C, which bars judicial review in some cases, valid?
The Judgment: What Was Decided
The thirteen judges wrote separate opinions, which ran to several hundred pages. A short "view of the majority" was signed by most of the judges, and it is this summary that lawyers cite. Its key points are:
- Golaknath overruled: Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights, so the 24th Amendment was held valid.
- Basic structure limit: The power to "amend" does not include the power to abrogate or change the Constitution's basic structure or framework.
- 25th Amendment: Largely upheld. The first part of Article 31C (protecting laws that give effect to Article 39(b) and (c)) was upheld, but the second part, which said such laws cannot be questioned in any court, was struck down.
- 29th Amendment: Upheld, subject to
0 Comments