A batch of petitions in the Supreme Court asks a legal question about how India's election machinery works: were decisions of the Election Commission of India (ECI), including those on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, taken by the full three-member Commission, or without the concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners? On 27 October 2026, a bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana heard the matter.
This post explains the law and the case in simple words. The case is pending. The Court has expressed no view on the merits, and the allegations below are those of the petitioners. We do not take sides, and we also give the ECI's reply.
The Election Commission in the Supreme Court
Five legal ideas behind the case, a timeline and a short quiz. Tap each card to read it.
Contents
Five Legal Ideas
Tap or click a card. These explain the law, not who is right.
Article 324 and the Commission
- Multi-member body: The Constitution allows the ECI to have a CEC and other Election Commissioners. In T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995), the Supreme Court upheld the multi-member Commission and said the CEC is not superior to the other Commissioners in decision-making.
- How decisions are taken: The statute on appointment and service conditions of the CEC and Election Commissioners says the Commission should, as far as possible, act by unanimity, and by majority where they differ. Please check the exact section in the current Act on India Code.
- Appointments: In Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023), a Constitution Bench said appointments should be made on the advice of a committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition and the CJI, until Parliament makes a law. Parliament then passed the 2023 Act, which changed the committee's make-up. The 2023 Act has itself been challenged, so please follow the Court's orders.
- Direct access: The petitions are under Article 32. See our explainers on writs and PIL.
What each side says, as reported
| Petitioners say | The ECI says |
|---|---|
| Several decisions on the SIR were taken in the ECI's name without the concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners, and a newspaper report is cited for this. | All three SIR orders (24 June 2025, 27 October 2025 and 14 May 2026) were issued on unanimous decisions. |
| The form for adding names to the roll, Form 6, was modified. | Form 6 was never amended, since only the Central Government can do so. |
| Voters may be excluded without adequate notice, hearing or a way to be restored. They seek booth-wise lists of deleted voters with reasons, and an independent audit. | A newspaper report is not evidence, and the plea against the CEC is not maintainable (Article 324(5)). A detailed reply is to follow. |
Timeline
The Case at a Glance
| Point | Details | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Lead case | Rakesh Kumar Singh v. Union of India (quo warranto-type plea against the CEC) | Reported |
| Connected petitions | Includes the petition by Rahul Gandhi and other opposition leaders (W.P.(C) 1351/2026), and others, including by Asaduddin Owaisi | Reported |
| Main allegation | Some ECI decisions, including on the SIR, were taken without the concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners | Allegation |
| ECI's stand (affidavit) | All SIR decisions were unanimous; Form 6 was not amended; a newspaper report is not evidence; the plea against the CEC is not maintainable (Art. 324(5)) | Reported |
| Bench on 27 Oct 2026 | CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, Justice V. Mohana | Reported |
| Order on 27 Oct 2026 | 10 days to the petitioners to file a rejoinder; tentatively listed on 17 Nov 2026 | Reported |
| Interim order against the CEC | None. An ex-parte order suspending the CEC was declined on 5 Oct 2026 | Reported |
| Final decision | None yet. The Court has expressed no view on the merits | Pending |
Quiz: How Much Did You Learn?
Q1. Which Article of the Constitution vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the Election Commission?
Q2. Under Article 324(5), the Chief Election Commissioner can be removed only in the manner and on the grounds applicable to whom?
Q3. What is the writ of quo warranto?
Q4. What did the Supreme Court do on 27 October 2026 in this batch of petitions, as reported?
Q5. Which Constitution Bench judgment (2023) laid down that appointments to the ECI should be made on the advice of a committee including the Leader of Opposition and the CJI, until Parliament made a law?
Answer key (if the quiz does not load)
Q1: Article 324. Q2: A Supreme Court judge. Q3: A writ asking by what authority a person holds a public office. Q4: Gave the petitioners 10 days to file a rejoinder and tentatively listed the matter on 17 November. Q5: Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has the Supreme Court said the Election Commission acted wrongly?
No. The Court has expressed no view on the merits. It has issued notice, taken the ECI's affidavit on record and allowed the petitioners time to reply.
Has the Chief Election Commissioner been suspended or removed?
No. On 5 October 2026 the Court declined an ex-parte interim order to suspend the CEC. A CEC can be removed only as a Supreme Court judge can be, under Article 324(5).
What is the ECI's reply?
As reported, its affidavit says all SIR decisions were taken unanimously, that Form 6 was not amended, and that a newspaper report relied on by the petitioners is not evidence. It also argues that the plea against the CEC is not maintainable.
Is the SIR itself under challenge now?
Earlier challenges to the SIR were heard by the Court and, as reported, the SIR was upheld on 27 May 2026. According to one report, the petition by Rahul Gandhi and others does not seek to reopen its validity. It questions how the ECI took its decisions. Other petitions in the batch raise their own points.
I am a voter. How do I check my name on the roll?
Use the official Election Commission voter portal (voters.eci.gov.in) or the Voter Helpline 1950 to check your name, and apply using the prescribed forms if your name is missing. Please follow the official notices for your State.
Conclusion
Elections depend on trust in the body that runs them, and courts decide such disputes on records and law, not on headlines. The Supreme Court will next look at the matter, tentatively, on 17 November 2026. Until then, it is best to read the court's orders and avoid guesswork.
Official and Press Sources for Reference
- Constitution (Article 324) and Acts: India Code
- Case status and orders: Supreme Court of India; voter services: Election Commission of India
- News reports used: LiveLaw and LawChakra
Last updated: October 31, 2026
0 Comments